Cast

B
Ben Feldman
as Andrew
C
Cristin Milioti
as Zelda
H
Henry Zebrowski
as Stu
L
Lenora Crichlow
as Stephie
C
Christina Kirk
as Lydia 'Big Bird'
K
Katey Sagal
as Narrator (voice)
B
Ben Falcone
as Howard
R
Ray Parker, Jr.
as Himself
S
Sarah Baker
as Jennifer
E
Echo Kellum
as Joseph
H
Hunter Payton
as Young Andrew
C
Colin McGurk
as Barista
J
John Gabriel Rodriquez
as Mike
L
Lea Thompson
as Lea Thompson
E
Eric Normington
as Bartender
N
Nancy Friedrich
as Nancy
M
Maggie Beal
as Young Zelda
C
Celeste Cook
as Theatre Patron
C
Chelsey Crisp
as Brooke
P
Patrick Carlyle
as Sage
J
Jensen Atwood
as Curt
E
Exie Booker
as Lt Taylor
Z
Zack Duhame
as Officer
C
Christian Gehring
as Gustav
M
Maurice Warfield
as Husband
T
Toby Huss
as Uncle Dave
W
Wayne Wilderson
as Dane
S
Sally Dworsky
as Guest
T
Tyler Ward
as Tyler Ward
T
Trevor Larcom
as Young Stu
M
Mindy Sterling
as Aunt Jo
H
Henry T. Yamada
as Cousin Beezy
V
Vivian Bang
as Emily Sloninsky
S
Steve Trzaska
as Silent Arnold
A
Americus Abesamis
as Doorman
G
Guerrin Gardner
as Sexy Nurse
N
Nicole Margulis
as Programmer / Fairy
A
Andrew Dinh
as Wallflower Employee
J
Josh Casaubon
as Frank
J
Josh Meyers
as Chad
J
Jessie Graff
as Abe Lincoln
L
Loresa Grigsby
as Bystander
M
Mario Esquer
as Middle Schooler
R
Ryan Jachetta
as Sparring Partner
E
Emily Arlook
as Key
K
Kenneth-Michael Glass
as Receptionist
J
J. Rene Pena
as Registration Woman
S
Sasha Wexler
as Gina
M
Marina Anderson
as Gina's mom
E
Elke Berry
as Greta
A
Alex Wyse
as Jordan
E
Eric Normington
as Coffee Cart Guy
T
Tyler Cook
as Handsome Guy
E
Elle Alexander
as Stair Climber
A
Andy Favreau
as Bruno
E
Eddie Alfano
as Xavier
H
Hunter Womack
as Maintenance Guy
R
Rebecca Rowley
as Bartender (2014)
T
Taji Coleman
as Mom
A
Amy Okuda
as Becky
H
Hal Devi
as Bouncer
B
Byron Wallace
as Young Boy
D
Darren Dupree Washington
as Cop
N
Nate Shelkey
as Apartment Manager
D
Dan Lauria
as Pete
S
Steve Agee
as Lewis
E
Evan Tyler Stallone
as Wallflower Employee
B
Brian Shakti
as Bobby
D
Dreama Walker
as Madeline
P
Patrick Heusinger
as Jay
W
Will McCormack
as Kurtz
R
Rashida Jones
as Whalen
P
Parvesh Cheena
as Dinesh
H
Hong Chau
as Lora

Crew

M
Michael Patrick Jann
Director
D
Donald Diego
Writer
E
Eric Appel
Director
L
Laura Gutin
Writer
T
Theresa Mulligan
Writer
B
Ben Queen
Writer
R
Ryan Koh
Writer
D
David Wain
Director