Why 'Wicked: For Good' Should Adapt The Book Ending

'Wicked: For Good' will likely adapt the happier musical ending instead of the book ending, but here's why it should go the darker, riskier route.

Cynthia Erivo is Elphaba in 'Wicked For Good', directed by Jon M. Chu. Photo: Universal Pictures.

Preview:

'Wicked' added in more elements from the book; however, it still more closely adapted the musical.
'Wicked: For Good' will likely do the same, and stick with the happy Hollywood ending.
It would be riskier, but if done right, a book ending adaptation in 'Wicked: For Good' would be best.

SPOILER ALERT: Some potential spoilers for ‘Wicked: For Good' below.

'Wicked' is based on the book by Gregory Maguire and musical by the same name, and while it does take elements from both, it leans more heavily into adapting the musical. Book fans tend to not love the musical as much and vice versa. This is because a lot of things were changed to make it work better for the stage, including removing some of the political plot points, especially when it comes to the animal rights, and completely changing the ending to give it the classic Hollywood ending that audiences like to see.

The book came first, and because of that, it is the true story in the mind of most readers. It goes more in depth and is unafraid to push boundaries when needed. Surely 'Wicked: For Good', the upcoming film sequel starring Ariana Grande as Glinda and Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba, will deliver the musical ending, but if director Jon M. Chu was willing to take a risk with the book ending, it would be the better option. Here's why.

'Wicked' Book Ending Explained

Jonathan Bailey is Fiyero Tigelaar in 'Wicked', directed by Jon M. Chu. Photo: Universal Pictures.

Even for those who have not read book or seen the musical, 'Wicked' made it quite clear that Elphaba and Fiyero (played by Jonathan Bailey), fall in love. By the time he arrives to Shiz, however, he is already married with children. The two end up having an affair, but he is spoken for.

During the resistance, he is murdered by the Wizard's secret police, the Gale Force. Elphaba casts a spell to try to save him, and she believes it succeeds, turning him into the Scarecrow. After waking up from a coma (and birthing their baby, who goes to live with their family, which is detailed further in the second book, 'Son of a Witch'), she sends the flying monkeys after the Scarecrow. When they tear him apart and realize that is not the case, Elphaba snaps, completely becoming the Wicked Witch of the West. This was the straw the broke the camel's back so to speak, no pun intended.

She descends into evil here, feeling like the Wizard (Jeff Goldblum), and the government, has taken everything from her. When Dorothy shows up, she panics and throws water at Elphaba, melting her and killing her. A tragic end to a tragic tale. Throughout the book, whenever she cries, even from when she was a baby, water burns her and hurts her. This is something the movie, and musical, completely ignores. The reason why is so that they can change the ending of her story.

How The 'Wicked' Musical Changes The Ending

Cynthia Erivo is Elphaba in 'Wicked', directed by Jon M. Chu. Photo: Universal Pictures.

In the musical, Elphaba's spell was successful and Fiyero becomes the Scarecrow. The rest of Dorothy's friends have a connection to the witch as well. The Cowardly Lion is the lion cub that her and Fiyero saved at Shiz, something that remains the same from the book, and the Tin Man is Boq (Ethan Slater). Nessarose gives him a love potion, hoping he will fall in love with her, but it shrinks his heart and transforms him instead. In the book, he is a former woodchopper named Nick Chopper, who has his limbs replaced with tin after being cursed.

Elphaba is still distraught over the events of the Wizard and the government and what they are doing to the animals of Oz, taking away their rights and their voices, but she has also simply had enough. When she learns that a young girl named Dorothy is coming to attempt to kill her, she goes along with it, planning out a way to escape Oz once and for all.

When the bucket of water is thrown on her, she hides under a trap door, making it look like she has melted away and died. Fiyero, who is now the Scarecrow, helps her escape and the two live together, happily ever after. While she surely misses Glinda, and Glinda thinks she is dead, she still gets to live with the love of her life away from all the things she despises about Oz.

Why The Book Ending Would Best Serve 'Wicked: For Good'

(L to R) Ariana Grande is Glinda and Cynthia Erivo is Elphaba in 'Wicked For Good', directed by Jon M. Chu. Photo: Universal Pictures.

For the most part, those that read the book first prefer the book and those that watch the musical first prefer the musical. There are many reasons, however, that 'Wicked: For Good' should lean into the darker ending and embrace what the book has to offer.

First of all, because of these changes, it would be nearly impossible to adapt the other books in the series. 'A Lion Among Men' could possibly become a sequel, telling the story of the Cowardly Lion, and 'Elphie: A Wicked Childhood' a prequel, but 'Son Of A Witch' and 'Out Of Oz' are completely off the table, now that Elphaba lives. These books expand on the world of Oz and tell intriguing stories that would make for great movies, but they need the right set-up to truly work.

It is difficult to pull off a dark ending in a way that will not make the readers want to throw their books out the window. Most interpretations of 'Wicked' are that Elphaba has finally found peace now. She has gone through so much in her life, losing everyone around her and watching her government rip the rights away from the animals that she loves. In the end she snaps, and then is finally laid to rest. While this is not exactly a happy ending, it fits her story and changing it simply does not feel right.

The saying the book is always better than the movie is a saying for a reason. If 'Wicked: For Good' chooses to let Elphaba die, it will be dark and tragic, yes, but it is also the story that was meant to be told and opens the door for more to come.