Moviefone santa logo
Trending
'Spider-Man: Brand New Day' Trailer
'Dune: Part Three' Teaser
'Masters of the Universe' Teaser
'Avengers: Doomsday' Teaser
MoviesTV ShowsStreamingIn TheatersComing SoonMovie ChartsTV Show ChartsShowtimesHighlightsNewsCelebritiesWhat to WatchNew TrailersMovie TheatersMovie ReviewsVideosMoviefone TVMade In Hollywood
The SubstanceThe SubstanceConclaveConclaveThe AccountantThe AccountantA Real PainA Real PainFlowFlowZero DayZero DayThe White LotusThe White LotusParadiseParadiseSeveranceSeveranceYellowjacketsYellowjackets
Highlights
  1. News

The 9 Most Entertaining Reality TV Judges Ever

Moviefone
September 10, 2015 - 1 min read
Google transparent preferred source badge

If you're given the seemingly cushy job of sitting comfortably at a panel mentoring hungry Hollywood newbies and spouting comments about something you're a supposed expert on, you should give it your all. Who are our favorite judges of all time? Take a look at 9 greats who spice up reality competition TV. 

RuPaul, 'RuPaul's Drag Race'

Nobody does it like RuPaul. A host and a judge, RuPaul is witty, wise, and sympathetic all at once. What an absolute joy to watch this gem on screen every single episode.  Memorable quote: “Impersonating Beyonce was not your destiny, child. ”

Tyra Banks, 'America's Next Top Model'

What would Tyra do? I often recite this manta to myself in a jam. Through all of "America's Next Top Model"s cycles, Tyra's zany antics, disguises, and over-the-top hammy dramatics have given us life. And she cares about the girls, too. Just ask Tiffany from Cycle 4 -- who she famously yelled at in a disappointed rage. All hail the woman who gave us smizing. "Tyramail!"  Memorable quote: "I was rooting for you. We were all rooting for you!" 

Michael Kors, 'Project Runway'

Those burns, though. Michael Kors has uttered some of the most random fashion criticism we have ever heard. From his baffled expressions and to his on-point sartorial observations, we can't get enough.  Memorable quote: All of them? Here's one. "Unless you are going to a Joan Crawford St. Paddy’s day party, who is wearing this blouse?”

Simon Cowell, 'American Idol' & "X Factor'

Simon is the judge we all love to hate. He may be mean, but he also knows what he's talking about. He created "One Direction," you guys. Admit it -- you enjoy his epically rude career-crushing insults and his crisp v-necks.  Memorable quote: "Do you have a singing teacher? Get a lawyer and sue her."

Mary Murphy, 'So You Think You Can Dance'

"So You Think You Can Dance"'s wacky Mary Murphy may be gone, but she is definitely not forgotten. Her presence (and scream) echoes in our dance-loving brains. Sure, she was shrill, loud, and in-your-face, but her enthusiasm and passion made up for it. Most of the time.  Memorable quote: "That samba puts you on the hot tamale train!"

Paula Abdul, 'American Idol'

We weren't always sure what Paula was talking about, but we know the girl has heart. When she was speaking, it was hard to look away... And Paula just wanted to see those contestants to succeed! As huge fans of the singer/dancer from back in her "Coldhearted Snake" days, she really can do no wrong in our eyes. Plus, she made Simon laugh. Memorable quote: "I don't know if we should give you a record deal or a strait jacket!" 

Adam Levine and Blake Shelton, 'The Voice'

So, Adam and Blake are technically coaches... but this "The Voice" duo had to be included here. Both are great on their own, but their bromance (and rivalry) brings them to another level. That banter, expertise, and adorableness set the singing competition apart.  Memorable quote: "Blake is the authority on all things One Direction" -Adam 

Tom Colicchio, 'Top Chef'

Tom Colicchio isn't the most flamboyant of judges, yet he still manages to be endlessly watchable. He knows food, and if he doesn't like yours, you'll know it.... especially if you under-salted your food. The charming and usually stoic chef's insightful criticism and faces of chagrin are the cream of the reality tv crop. It's clear when #TomColicchioIsNotImpressed. Memorable quote: "Did you ever think about -- if you're on the winning side or losing side -- am I gonna win this with a chicken salad sandwich?"

Moviefone
Article by Moviefone
Moviefone Writers

From Our Partners

Global Grind - What’s Black On Netflix: March 2026
Global Grind - What’s New & Black On Netflix: February 2026
Global Grind - Lil Mama Stars As Deb Antney In ALLBLK’s New Biopic ‘Deb Is Boss’

More News on Moviefone

Jeff Bridges and Allison Janney to Lead ‘Minions & Monsters’
Jeff Bridges and Allison Janney to Lead ‘Minions & Monsters’
Best Ryan Gosling Movies of All Time Ranked
Best Ryan Gosling Movies of All Time Ranked
Emily Blunt and Cillian Murphy Returning for ‘A Quiet Place: Part III’
Emily Blunt and Cillian Murphy Returning for ‘A Quiet Place: Part III’
Jason Clarke Joining Viola Davis in ‘Ally Clark’
Jason Clarke Joining Viola Davis in ‘Ally Clark’
‘Firefly’ Animated Revival Series in Development
‘Firefly’ Animated Revival Series in Development
‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer’ Actor Nicholas Brendon Dead at 54
‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer’ Actor Nicholas Brendon Dead at 54

Explore Movies and TV Shows

Avatar: Fire and Ash Movie Poster
Movies
Sinners Movie Poster
Movie Charts
Hoppers Movie Poster
Movies In Theaters
The Odyssey Movie Poster
Movies Coming Soon
Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man Movie Poster
Movie Release Calendar
Anaconda Movie Poster
Movie Genres
The Housemaid Movie Poster
Streaming
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms Series Poster
TV Shows
Young Sherlock Series Poster
TV Show Charts

Follow Moviefone

FacebookXInstagramYouTubeLinkedInRedditTikTokNewsletterWidgets

Latest Trailers

'Finding Satoshi' Trailer2:44
'Finding Satoshi' Trailer
'The Law According to Lidia Poët' Season 3 Trailer1:37
'The Law According to Lidia Poët' Season 3 Trailer
'Spider-Man: Brand New Day' Trailer2:40
'Spider-Man: Brand New Day' Trailer
'Star Wars: Maul - Shadow Lord' Season 1 Trailer2:04
'Star Wars: Maul - Shadow Lord' Season 1 Trailer
'Off Campus' Teaser1:02
'Off Campus' Teaser

Movie and TV Reviews

Top Movies

The Substance poster
The Substance
Have you ever dreamt of a better version of yourself?
71
Conclave poster
Conclave
What happens behind these walls will change everything.
72
The Accountant poster
The Accountant
Calculate your choices.
71

Top Series

Zero Day poster
Zero Day
Truth has been weaponized.
70
The White Lotus poster
The White Lotus
Same luxury. New reservations.
76
Paradise poster
Paradise
The truth lies outside.
74
Moviefone xmas logo
MoviesTV ShowsStreamingShowtimesWhat to WatchVideosNews
AboutContact UsSitemapTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
FacebookXInstagramYouTubeLinkedInRedditTikTokNewsletterWidgets
Google preferred source badge
Copyright © 2026 Moviefone Media LLC
Asset 1This product uses the TMDb API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDb.